A family swim at a quiet creek in Queensland, Australia turned into one of the most shared ghost photos on the internet, but almost nothing about the viral version of the story is accurate. The image has been reposted millions of times across Facebook, Instagram, and international news sites. Each time it travels, the details shift a little further from the truth. The creek becomes a lake. A teenager becomes a little girl. And a blurry shape in the water becomes an unmistakable face.
The original photo, and the real drowning connected to the location, deserve a closer look.
What Actually Happened
In 2014, Kim Davison took a photo while swimming with her friend Jessie Lu and several children at Murphy’s Hole, a deep swimming spot on Lockyer Creek near the small town of Helidon in southeast Queensland. The photo was later posted to the Toowoomba Ghost Chasers Facebook page, where it sparked immediate debate.
Davison described what she saw in the image: “I’m holding the little girl and that white head next to me with horns is not human, I can promise you that.” She also claimed to see something else in the frame, describing what appeared to be a hand near her shoulder. “Its fingers are on my shoulder and on my daughter’s arm,” she said. “They are long skeletal type fingers.”
Lu backed up the account and stressed that the group was small. “There was only three children there on that day,” she said. “Two adults in the water and two adults on the bank. One was taking the photo by her phone camera.” She also noted that “the older girl had trouble in the water on two occasions that day,” and claimed that “we have had two IT specialists look at this photo.”
Neither the IT specialists nor their findings were ever named or published.
The Drowning That Made It Go Viral
The photo might have stayed inside a small paranormal Facebook group if not for what happened next. Other users on the page began digging into the history of Murphy’s Hole. They found a newspaper obituary in the Brisbane Courier, dated November 22, 1915, that described a tragedy at the exact same spot.
The notice read: “Doreen O’Sullivan, aged 13 years, eldest daughter of Mr. James O’Sullivan was accidentally drowned whilst bathing in the Lockyer Creek on Friday afternoon.” It went on to note that “the spot, which has always been considered dangerous, is known as Murphy’s Hole, and is over 20ft. deep.” The report added that nearly an hour passed before her body was recovered, and that convent school children dressed in white marched beside the hearse at her funeral.
A grave belonging to a 13-year-old girl with the same name was also reportedly found. That discovery, combined with the obituary, turned a debatable photo into a full-blown viral sensation. By March 2015, the story had spread through the Daily Mail, Yahoo News Australia, and dozens of international outlets.
How the Legend Mutated Online
This is where the story gets interesting from a different angle. As the photo spread, the facts quietly changed. And almost every change made the story more dramatic.
Lockyer Creek, a winding inland waterway, became “a lake.” Doreen O’Sullivan, who was 13 years old at the time of her death, became “a little girl.” The blurry white shape Davison described as having “horns” morphed into a pale child’s face that supposedly matched the features of the drowned girl. No photograph of Doreen has ever been produced for comparison, so that claim has no basis.
Foreign-language versions of the story drifted even further. Some added details about a skeletal hand gripping Davison’s shoulder. Others described her daughter’s leg being “snagged” by something beneath the surface, or claimed Davison felt a presence following her home. Some versions stated that Davison herself tracked down the obituary by going door to door in Helidon, when in fact it was Facebook users who found the newspaper clipping.
The viral copy that still circulates on Instagram and Facebook today, often posted by accounts like “Extremely Interesting Facts,” typically includes most of these embellishments. It presents them as a tidy package: woman takes photo, sees ghost, discovers drowned girl, story confirmed. The real sequence was messier, slower, and driven by strangers on the internet rather than a single dramatic discovery.
The Skeptic’s Read
Look at the original photo. The shape in question is a bright, blown-out white form at water level, positioned right next to an arm that appears to have just surfaced. It is a low-resolution phone image taken in natural light on a reflective body of water.
One unnamed skeptic, quoted through the Inquisitr, put it plainly: “The eye sees what it wants to see.” They added that it appeared to be “nothing more than a splash of water” and pointed out that a child facing away from the camera had their left arm just breaking the surface, which would cause exactly the kind of bright, irregular shape visible in the frame.
This is a textbook case of pareidolia, the well-documented human tendency to see faces and figures in random visual patterns. We do it with clouds, wood grain, burnt toast, and especially with low-quality photographs taken near water. The Skeptoid podcast has covered this phenomenon extensively in the context of ghost photography, noting that water, glass, and low light are the most common triggers.
It is also worth noting the order of events. The obituary for Doreen O’Sullivan was found after the photo went viral. The ghost interpretation came first. The historical tragedy was discovered second and then attached to the image retroactively. This is a common pattern in paranormal cases: an ambiguous image draws attention, and then someone finds a local death or disaster to explain it.
But a Real Girl Did Drown There
None of the skeptical explanations change the fact that Doreen O’Sullivan was a real person. She was 13 years old. She was the eldest daughter of James O’Sullivan. She drowned while swimming at Murphy’s Hole on a Friday afternoon in November 1915, at a spot the newspaper itself described as dangerous. Her body took nearly an hour to recover from water over 20 feet deep. Her classmates walked beside her hearse in their white school uniforms.
That is not a legend. It is a documented death, confirmed by a contemporary newspaper and a matching grave. The viral photo may or may not show anything unusual. But the place where it was taken has a real history, and a real girl lost her life there over a century ago.
Whether the shape in the water is a ghost, a splash, or a trick of light and shadow, Doreen O’Sullivan’s story is the one worth remembering.
Seen something unexplained? Email Reports@ParaRational.com





